The release of the fifth major expansion - Abbey and the Mayor - may well have been the decisive factor. None of this was really a problem - although it did generate heated discussion - so long as players were informed about the two possibilities and agreed on which to use. Sticking to 1st edition rules meant that RGG needed to adapt every subsequent expansion to fit - so even if 1st edition rules are more 'authentic' for the basic game, they become less 'authentic' the moment you add an expansion into the mix. So, for example, when the earlier RGG edition of Traders and Builders talks about the pig giving a bonus point and bringing the total to 5, that's an adaptation of the original German rules, in which the total is 4. To date, only two of the 15-odd expansions released have been authored by RGG, and neither involve new rules. Also, every single FAQ, and most expansions to the game, has 3rd edition rules in mind. Logically enough, since its basis is the original HiG rules, ZMG uses 3rd edition scoring, and RGG ultimately also abandoned 1st edition scoring - this document uses 3rd edition rules. The usual arguments for this decision revolved around consistency (it would confuse people to change the rules) and authenticity (1st edition rules are the ones that won GotY, after all). While 3rd edition rules have been used in Germany since 2002, RGG initially chose to stick with the 1st edition rules. Where does this document stand with farms? Red scores 3 points.īlue scores 3 points for each farmer = total 6 points. Red scores no points.īlue scores 3 points - even he has 2 followers on different fields. Making the notion of 'farmer' scoring slightly misleading and difficult to grasp for younger players (this, essentially, was the jury's objection).īlue has the majority of fields around this city.īlue scores 4 points - even he has 2 followers on different fields. Also, in the 1st edition rules, the farms weren't actually scored directly, but only indirectly, The great virtue of the 3rd edition rules is that you don't have to keep track of which cities have been scored, only which farms - and since you should remove the farmers after a given farm has been scored, it isn't overly difficult to do so. But like 1st edition rules, each city could only be scored once, meaning you still had to keep track of which cities had scored 3 points and which not.ģrd edition rules came swiftly and removed that qualification, so that each city could now be scored multiple times. The 2nd edition rules changed to scoring farms from the perspective of the farms - pick a farm, count the farmers on it, and the player with the most farmers scores 3 points for every city touching the farm. The original 1st edition farmer rules were considered to be too difficult by the jury and they were changed although this led to calls for Carcassonne to be stripped of the award, since the game that won was not actually the game subsequently sold as the GotY. Then play moved on to the next city.Ģnd edition rules followed almost immediately - after Carcassonne won Game of the Year (GotY), in fact. The player with the majority of those farmers scored 4 points. The 1st edition rules were scored from the perspective of the cities themselves: that is, you picked a city, and counted the number of farmers on all the farms touching that city. 2 Where does this document stand with farms?.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |